SongsBrew, brought to you by Music24

Hello You.

Last week we handed you the A&R job. This week it's robots.

My first experience of the talkbox, where I actually knew what one was, was 2Pac. I remember hearing it when I was a lot younger and it was mind-blowing. I hadn't seen Bon Jovi use one on stage by then either.

The reason it's back on my mind is that some smaller artists are making music with them again on TikTok, and they're really cool. It got me thinking about how far back the tech goes, the best examples of it, and more importantly, can I make this work at home? Turns out you can.

There are three robot vocals and they get mixed up all the time - even by me. Here's how to tell them apart.

A mouth full of guitar

Put on California Love. That voice in the hook is Roger Troutman, playing live - super cool. The sound goes up a tube into his mouth, his mouth shapes the words, and a mic picks it up. Listen for the t's and k's. That's a real mouth in action.

Then Livin' on a Prayer. The "wah-wah" bit is Richie Sambora doing the same thing on guitar.

Speak and synth

Now Harder, Better, Faster, Stronger. No tube this time. That's very likely a vocoder: a voice laid over a synth, so you get the rhythm of speech but every note is the keyboard's. Flat, hissy, robotic.

Mr Blue Sky has one too. At the very end the robot says "please turn me over", as in flip the record.

Snap to it

Believe (a secret favorite). Cher's voice, and it jumps from note to note instead of sliding. That's Auto-Tune with the speed turned all the way up. Warner wanted it taken out and Cher refused, glad she did tbh.

Her team then told everyone it was a vocoder pedal, and kept that up for about a year. It wasn't.

I really believe Believe is a top-tier track. There's no reason not to enjoy it, no matter what you normally listen to.

Older than you'd think

Talking instruments were in films by 1940. The Sonovox gave Casey Jr. the train his voice in Dumbo. The vocoder came out of Bell Labs (yes, them again) and was used for secret phone calls in the war. Peter Frampton's Show Me the Way was everywhere in 1976, and Zapp's More Bounce to the Ounce took it into funk in 1980.

Can you tell?

Hide and Seek by Imogen Heap. Sounds like a vocoder, but isn't. It's a harmonizer she plugged in after her computer died, so it's none of the three.

And Daft Punk used all three: Around the World (talkbox), Harder, Better, Faster, Stronger (vocoder), One More Time (Auto-Tune). At a certain point it becomes hard to tell the difference, unless you have a trained ear.

Back on the tube

Mr. TalkBox played the intro to 24K Magic. Neko Suave from Chicago picked one up at 18 after hearing Roger Troutman and used it on Waterfalls. And Bon Jovi brought the talkbox riff back on Living Proof in 2024.

Can I do this at home?

Yes. Though, results may vary...

  • Free: the mda Talkbox plugin. It's really a vocoder, but you'll hear the effect and it is fun.

  • Almost free: an old speaker, a funnel glued over it, clear tubing from the aquarium section of a pet shop, and a mic. Tube in your mouth, mouth the words, keep the volume low. If you do make one, please send us photos.

  • The proper pedal: the MXR M222.

A short, incomplete list

California Love. More Bounce to the Ounce. Show Me the Way. Mr Blue Sky. Around the World. Harder, Better, Faster, Stronger. Believe. Woods. Livin' on a Prayer.

Playlist at the bottom packed with sliding, tubey vocals.

Add your latest listens to the Crate, our community page.

Playing a show soon? Put it on our Gigs page, it's free.

Making music? Send it to us.

See you next Thursday.