Short answer

If you want another algorithm, try Apple Music's Discovery Station or Last.fm. If you want people, listen to KEXP or NTS, both free to stream, or sign up for a newsletter such as Bandcamp Notes or The Line of Best Fit. SongsBrew is a free weekly email every Thursday, written by people.

About SongsBrew: a free weekly music newsletter, one email every Thursday, written by people.

Get one good find every Thursday

SongsBrew is free: one email every Thursday, written by people.

Free. Unsubscribe any time. I consent to receive newsletters via email. Terms of use and Privacy policy.

What kind of alternative do I actually need?

It depends on what went wrong.

  • If Discover Weekly is fine but stale, you need a different algorithm, or a reset of the one you have.

  • If it keeps landing on songs you dislike or tracks that feel machine-made, you need a source with a person behind it.

  • If you simply don't want to do the work, you need something that arrives on its own: a station you leave on, or an email once a week.

Most people end up with two: one algorithm for volume and one human source for surprise.

Can I fix Discover Weekly before replacing it?

Often, yes. The usual problem is that sleep, kids or focus playlists count as your taste. You can exclude them from your taste profile, and Premium listeners can use the genre filters at the top of the playlist. We go through it step by step in why Discover Weekly keeps repeating the same songs.

Which apps recommend music differently from Spotify?

Apple Music's Discovery Station. A station that plays only music you have not played on Apple Music before, and does not repeat a song while it runs. You find it under "Stations for You". It needs an Apple Music subscription. Good if you already pay for Apple Music, or if your main complaint is hearing songs you know.

Last.fm. Free. It records what you play across services (it calls this scrobbling) and recommends music and events from that history. Because it sees your listening from several apps, not one, it can break a single app's loop. A paid Pro tier adds more control; the basics stay free. Good if you listen in more than one place.

Both are still algorithms. They will learn from you the same way Discover Weekly does, so the same rules apply: what you play is what they learn.

Which radio stations are good for finding new music?

KEXP. A listener-supported station in Seattle with a free live stream and a two-week archive you can play on demand. Its DJs pick what plays. Good if you want someone to tell you why a song is on.

NTS. Two live channels of shows by resident and guest presenters, plus an archive of past shows and music-only "Infinite Mixtapes". NTS says it is free, with no ads, 24/7. Good if you like to wander from show to show and see where you end up.

Radio is the closest thing to Discover Weekly with a human on the other end: you press play and it keeps going. The difference is that the presenter does not start from your history.

The archives are the part most people miss. Find one show you like, then play the last few episodes of it. A presenter you agreed with three times is a good bet for a fourth.

Do any of these cost money?

Most of them are free.

  • Free: KEXP, NTS, Last.fm's basic tier, Bandcamp Notes, The Line of Best Fit's weekly posts, and SongsBrew.

  • Paid: Apple Music, which Discovery Station needs, and The Amplifier, which needs a New York Times subscription.

  • Optional: KEXP asks listeners to donate, NTS sells a supporter option for live tracklists, and Last.fm and The Line of Best Fit have paid tiers with extras.

You can replace Discover Weekly without paying anything. If one of the free sources ends up giving you most of your new music, that is the one worth supporting.

Is a newsletter a good replacement?

For many people it is the best fit, because it arrives once a week like Discover Weekly did, and someone has listened to every pick. A few we checked:

  • Bandcamp Notes, from the Bandcamp Daily editors: usually one artist per issue, free.

  • The Line of Best Fit: a free weekly Friday Dispatch, with an optional paid tier.

  • The Amplifier from The New York Times: weekly song picks by a person, for Times subscribers.

  • SongsBrew: that's us. A free weekly email every Thursday, written by people, sent to about 26,000 subscribers.

The longer list, with what each one is good for, is in the best free newsletters to discover new music.

Sources

Name
What it is
Free or paid
How often
Checked
Link
Apple Music Discovery Station
Station of songs you have not played on Apple Music
Needs an Apple Music subscription
Continuous
Checked on
Last.fm
Tracks your listening across services and recommends from it
Free; paid Pro tier
Ongoing
Checked on
KEXP
Listener-supported radio station in Seattle
Free to stream
Live, plus a two-week archive
Checked on
NTS
Online radio, two live channels and an archive
Free
24/7
Checked on
Bandcamp Notes
Newsletter by the Bandcamp Daily editors
Free
About once or twice a week
Checked on
The Line of Best Fit
Friday Dispatch roundup and artist primers
Free; optional paid tier
Weekly
Checked on
The Amplifier (New York Times)
Weekly song picks from a person
For Times subscribers
Weekly
Checked on
Spotify: exclude from your taste profile
How to keep playlists out of your recommendations
Free and Premium
Takes effect within 48 hours
Checked on
SongsBrew
Weekly music newsletter, written by people
Free
Every Thursday
Checked on

Prices and frequency as shown on each site on the date checked.

Which one should I try first?

Start with one of each kind and give it a month.

  1. Fix what you can in Spotify: exclude the background playlists.

  2. Leave KEXP or NTS on for an evening a week.

  3. Sign up for one or two newsletters and read four issues before you judge them.

After a month you will know which source keeps handing you songs you save. Keep that one and drop the rest. If you want to step away from algorithms altogether, read how to find new music without the Spotify algorithm. If you are worried about AI tracks, see how to avoid AI-generated songs in your recommendations. More ideas, old and new, are in 7 ways to find new music and the find new music guide.

Get one good find every Thursday

SongsBrew is free: one email every Thursday, written by people.

Free. Unsubscribe any time. I consent to receive newsletters via email. Terms of use and Privacy policy.