Short answer

Let people pick, not the algorithm. Follow one or two writers or DJs whose taste you trust: a weekly newsletter, a radio station like KEXP or NTS, a site like Bandcamp Daily. Save what you like to one playlist and keep Spotify as the player. SongsBrew is a free weekly email, written by people, every Thursday.

About SongsBrew: a free weekly music newsletter, one email every Thursday, written by people.

Get one good find every Thursday

SongsBrew is free: one email every Thursday, written by people.

Free. Unsubscribe any time. I consent to receive newsletters via email. Terms of use and Privacy policy.

Why does Spotify keep giving me the same music?

Recommendation playlists start from what you already play and what people with similar habits play. That is good at finding more of the same and bad at finding something you did not know you wanted. If you listen to one mood for a month, you get more of that mood. If you play an old favourite on repeat, it comes back.

That is the loop people describe on Spotify's own forum: Discover Weekly bringing back songs they already have, the same few genres every week, "music quicksand". You can nudge it by hiding songs and liking others, but you are still training a machine on your past. If you want the full story of why it repeats, we wrote it up in Why does Discover Weekly keep repeating the same songs?. The short version: the fix is outside the app.

What works better than the algorithm?

A person with taste and a reason to share it. In practice that means four kinds of source.

Newsletters. One email a week from someone who listened to a lot so you do not have to. You learn their taste over a few issues, and when it matches yours, it saves you hours. We list the free ones we checked in What are the best free newsletters to discover new music?.

Radio with real DJs. Stations like KEXP in Seattle, which is listener-supported, and NTS stream for free, around the clock, and the people choosing the songs are named and on air. Leave one on while you work and keep a note open.

Music sites and blogs. Bandcamp Daily writes about records on Bandcamp several times a week, with a strong lean towards independent artists. Aquarium Drunkard has been writing about old and new music for years; part of it is free, the rest is for members.

Other people. Friends, the record shop, the opening act at a gig. The oldest method still has the best hit rate, because you already know whose taste you trust.

Sources

Name
What it is
Free or paid
How often
Checked
Link
SongsBrew
Weekly music email written by people, about 26,000 subscribers
Free
Every Thursday
Checked on
Bandcamp Daily
Bandcamp's own editorial site: features, lists, Album of the Day
Free to read
Several posts most weekdays
Checked on
KEXP
Listener-supported radio from Seattle, streamed online
Free, funded by donations
Live 24/7
Checked on
NTS
Online radio with two live channels and an archive of past shows
Free; optional paid Supporters membership
Live 24/7
Checked on
Aquarium Drunkard
Music journal: reviews, interviews, mixtapes, radio
Part free; full articles for members ($9.99 a month or $100
Several posts most days
Checked on
NPR New Music Friday
Podcast picking the best albums out each week
Free
Every Friday
Checked on

Prices and frequency as shown on each site on the date checked.

Do I have to stop using Spotify?

No. Spotify is a good player and a large catalogue. The problem is only who decides what goes in. Keep the app, and change the input.

A few small things help:

  • Make one playlist called something like "To hear". Everything a person recommends goes in there, from any source.

  • Play that playlist instead of Discover Weekly for a month and see what sticks.

  • When a song lands, look up who wrote about it first and read their next pick. That is how you find your curator.

If you want to own what you find, buy it on Bandcamp, straight from the artist or label. For free and legal downloads, we keep a list in Free legal MP3 sites.

How do I keep it from turning into homework?

Pick fewer sources, not more. One newsletter, one radio station and one site is enough. Ten newsletters you never open are worse than one you read every week.

Give it a fixed slot. Thursday evening with the newsletter, Friday morning with the new releases, a station on in the background while you cook. People who stop discovering music rarely lose interest; they lose the habit. If that is where you are, Cure your musical rut has ideas for getting it back, and 7 ways to find new music covers the basics.

Accept a low hit rate. If one song in ten stays with you, that is a good week. The algorithm gives you songs you will not skip; people give you songs you will remember. Those are different jobs.

What about AI-generated songs in my recommendations?

That is the newer reason people leave the algorithm. AI-made tracks now turn up in recommendation playlists, and there is no simple switch on Spotify that keeps them out. Getting your picks from named people is the most reliable filter we know. We go through what each service does about it in How do I avoid AI-generated songs in my recommendations?.

For the bigger picture on what streaming did to discovery, read You discovery is a lie and They killed your playlists.

Where does SongsBrew fit in?

SongsBrew is one of those people-made sources. It is a free email every Thursday, written by people, with the songs and records we think are worth your time. About 26,000 people read it. We are part of Music24.

If our taste matches yours, it does the picking for you once a week. If it does not, the other sources on this page will, and the rest of our find new music guide has more.

Get one good find every Thursday

SongsBrew is free: one email every Thursday, written by people.

Free. Unsubscribe any time. I consent to receive newsletters via email. Terms of use and Privacy policy.